Haslanger, Marx, and the Social Ontology of Unitary Theory: Debating Capitalism’s Relationship to Race and Gender
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25365/jso-2022-7441Keywords:
Sally Haslanger, Nancy Fraser, Capitalism, Patriarchy, White Supremacy, Social Ontology, Marxist-FeminismAbstract
Taking up a recent critique of Nancy Fraser by Sally Haslanger, this paper defends the primary thesis of Marxist-Feminist unitarytheory that the systematic reproduction of modern forms of racial and gendered oppression is due to their co-articulation with thereproduction of capitalist social relations against three criticisms offered by Haslanger. It develops its defense of Fraser’s articulation of unitary theory by acknowledging a social ontological deficit in that theory insofar as it does not contain a theory of thesocial construction of human kinds and amending this deficit by drawing on revised aspects of Haslanger’s own work. It arguesthat the global reproduction of race and gender as hierarchical social relations is a consequence of the reproduction of capitalism although local gender and race kinds are asymmetrically co-constituted by non-capitalist social practices.
References
Adorno, T. 2000. Introduction to Sociology. Standford University Press.
Arruzza, C. 2014. “Remarks on Gender.” Viewpoint Magazine URL https://viewpointmag.com/2014/09/02/remarks-on-gender/.
Arruzza, C. 2015. “Logic or History? The Political Stakes of Marxist-Feminst Theory.” Viewpoint Magazine URL https://viewpointmag.com/2015/06/23/logic-or-history-the-political-stakes-of-marxist-feminist-theory/.
Arruzza, C. 2016. “Functionalist, Determinist, Reductionist: Social Reproduction Feminism and its Critics.” Science & Society 80 (1): 9–30, URL https://doi.org/10.1521/siso.2016.80.1.9.
Bair, J. 2010. “On Difference and Capital.” Signs 36 (1): 203–226, URL https://doi.org/10.1086/652912.
Bakker, I., and S. Gill. 2004. “Ontology, Methods, Hypothesis.” Power, Production, and Social Reproduction, edited by I. Bakker, S. Gill, et al., New York: Palgrave.
Bensaïd, D. 2002. Marx for Our Times. London: Verso.
Bhattacharya, T. 2017. Social Reproduction Theory. London: Pluto.
Campbell, M. 1993. “Marx’s Concept of Economic Relations and the Method of ‘Capital’.” Marx’s Method in ‘Capital’, edited by F. Mosley, New Jersey: Humanities Press, 135–156.
Chang, H. 1985. “Toward a Marxist Theory of Racism: Two Essays by Harry Chang.” Review of Radical Political Economics 17 (3): 34–35, URL https://doi.org/10.1177/048661348501700303.
Chen, C. 2013. “The Limit Point of Capitalist Equality.” Endnotes Collective 3: 202–223.
Das, R. 2012. “Reconceptualizing Capitalism: Forms of Subsumption of Labor, Class Struggle, and Uneven Development.” Review of Radical Political Economics 4 (2): 177–200, URL https://doi.org/10.1177/0486613411423895.
Dawson, M. 2016. “Hidden in Plain Sight: A Note on Legitimation Crisis and the Racial Order.” Critical Historical Studies 3 (1): 142–161, URL https://doi.org/10.1086/685540.
De’Ath, A. S. 2018. “Gender and Social Reproduction.” The SAGE Handbook of Frankfurt School Critical Theory, edited by B. Best, W. Bonefeld, and C. O’Kane, Sage Publications, 1534–1550.
Echeverría, B. 2014. “Use-Value: Ontology and Semiotics.” Radical Philosophy 188: 24–38.
Elson, D. 2015. “The Value Theory of Labor.” Value The Representation of Labor in Capitalilsm, edited by D. Elson, London: Verso, 115–180.
Epstein, B. 2009. “Ontological individualism reconsidered.” Synthese 166 (1): 187–213, URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-007-9272-8.
Ferguson, S. 2020. Women and Work. London: Pluto.
Fields, B., and K. Fields. 2012. Racecraft. London: Verso.
Fraser, N. 2014. “Behind Marx’s Hidden Abode.” New Left Review 86: 55–72.
Fraser, N., and R. Jaeggi. 2018. Capitalism: A Conversation in Critical Theory. Cambridge: Polity.
Gonzalez, M., and J. Neton. 2013. “The Logic of Gender.” Endnotes, edited by E. Collective, et al., Glassgow: Bell and Bain, volume 3, 56–91.
Grüner, E. 2020. The Haitian Revolution: Capitalism, Slavery, and Counter- Modernity. Cambridge: Polity.
Harootunian, H. 2015. Marx After Marx: History and Time in the Expansion of Capitalism. New York: Columbia University Press.
Haslanger, S. 2012. Resisting Reality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Haslanger, S. 2014. “Race, intersectionality, and method: a reply to critics.” Philosophical Studies 171 (1): 109–119, URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-013-0244-1.
Haslanger, S. 2016. “What is a (social) structural explanation?” Philosophical Studies 173 (1): 113–130, URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-014-0434-5.
Haslanger, S. 2017. “Racism, Ideology, and Social Movements.” Res Philosophica 94 (1): 1–22, URL https://doi.org/10.11612/resphil.1547.
Haslanger, S. 2018. “What is a Social Practice?” Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements 82: 231–247, URL https://doi.org/10.1017/S1358246118000085.
Haslanger, S. 2019a. “Disciplined Bodies and Ideology Critique.” Glass—Bead URL https://www.glass-bead.org/article/disciplined-bodies-and-ideology-critique/, (Accessed 2020/02/16).
Haslanger, S. 2019b. “Haslanger’s Reply to Glasgow, Jeffers, and Spencer.” What is Race: Four Philosophical Views, edited by J. Glasgow, S. Haslanger, C. Jeffers, and Q. Spencer, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 150–175, URL https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780190610173.001.0001.
Haslanger, S. 2020a. “Failures of Methodological Individualism: The Materiality of Social Systems.” Journal of Social Philosophy URL https://doi.org/10.1111/josp.12373.
Haslanger, S. 2020b. “Why I Don’t Believe in Patriarchy: Comments on Kate Manne’s ‘Down Girl’.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 101 (1): 220–229, URL https://doi.org/10.1111/phpr.12697.
Heinrich, M. 2012. An Introduction to the Three Volumes Of Marx’s Capital. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Heng, G. 2020. The Invention of Race in the European Middle Ages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Horne, G. 2020. The Dawning of the Apocalypse. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Ince, O. U. 2022. “Deprovincializing Racial Capitalism: John Crawfurd and Settler Colonialism in India.” American Political Science Review 116 (1): 144–160, URL https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055421000939.
Isaac, B. 2006. The Invention of Racism in Classical Antiquity. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Jaffe, A. 2020. Social Reproduction Theory and the Socialist Horizon. New York: Pluto.
Kyriakides, C., and R. D. Torres. 2012. Race Defaced. Standford: Standford University Press.
Lotz, C. 2014. The Capitalist Schema: Time, Money, and the Culture of Abstraction. New York: Lexington Books.
Lukács, G. 1967. Conversations With Lukács. London: Merlin.
Manne, K. 2017. Down Girl: The Logic Of Misogyny. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Manning, F. T. C. 2015. “Closing the Conceptual Gap.” Viewpoint Magazine URL https://viewpointmag.com/2015/05/04/closing-the-conceptual-gap-a-response-to-cinzia-arruzzas-remarks-on-gender/.
Marx, K. 1973[1857]. Grundrisse. New York: Penguin.
Marx, K. 1976[1867]. Capital Volume I. New York: Penguin.
Marx, K. 2010[1868]. “Letter of July 11, 1868 to Ludwig Kugelmann.” Marx and Engels Collected Works, New York: Lawrence and Wishart, volume 43, 67–69.
McCoskey, D. 2012. Race: Antiquity and its Legacy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Murray, P. 1988. Marx’s Theory of Scientific Knowledge. New Jersey: Humanities Press International.
Murray, P. 2017. The Mismeasure of Wealth. Leiden: Brill Academic Publishers.
Murray, P., and J. Schuler. 2016. “Social Form and the ‘Purely Social’: On the Kind of Sociality Involved in Value.” The Social Ontology of Capitalism, edited by D. Krier, and M. P. Worrell, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Negri, A. 1988. “Archaeology and project: The mass worker and the social worker.” Revolution Retrieved: Selected Writings on Marx, Keynes, Capitalist Crisis and New Social Subjects 1967-83, London: Red Notes.
Postone, M. 1993. Time, Labor, And Social Domination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Reichelt, H. 2007. “Marx’s Critique of Economic Categories: Reflections on the Problem of Validity in the Dialectical Method of Presentation in Capital.” Historical Materialism 15: 3–52, URL https://doi.org/10.1163/156920607X245823.
Roberts, W. C. 2009. “Abstraction and Productivity.” Karl Marx and Contemporary Philosophy, edited by A. Chitty, and M. McIvor, New York: Palgrave, 188–201.
Robinson, C. 2000. Black Marxism. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Rodney, W. 2019. The Groundings With My Brothers. London: Verso.
Roediger, D. 2017. Class, Race, and Marxism. London: Verso.
Roediger, D., and E. Esch. 2014. The Production of Difference. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Rouse, J. 2007. “Practice Theory.” Handbook of the Philosophy of Anthropology and Sociology, edited by S. Turner, and M. Risjord, Oxford: Elsevier, Handbook of the Philosophy of Science, volume 15, 499–540.
Sáenz De Sicilia, A. 2016. The Problem of Subsumption in Kant, Hegel, and Marx. Kingston University, (PhD thesis).
Schmidt, A. 1971. The Concept of Nature in Marx. London: Verso.
Sewell, W. H. 1992. “A Theory of Structure: Duality, Agency, and Transformation.” American Journal of Sociology 98 (1): 1–29, URL https://doi.org/10.1086/229967.
Tomba, M. 2012. Marx’s Temporalities. Leiden: Brill.
Tombazos, S. 2014. Time in Marx: The Categories of Time in Marx’s Capital. Leiden: Brill.
Toscano, A., and B. Bhandar. 2015. “Race, Real Estate, and Real Abstraction.” Radical Philosophy 194: 8–17.
Vogel, L. 2013. Marxism and The Oppression of Women. Chicago: Haymarket.
Walker, G. 2016. “The Feudal Remanant and the Historical Outside.” The Sublime Perversion of Capital, Durham: Duke University Press.
Whitaker, C. 2019. Black Metaphors: How Modern Racism Emerged from Medieval Race Thinking. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Wood, E. M. 1995. “Capitalism and human emancipation.” Democracy Against Capitalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 264–283.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Aaron Berman
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
